| Jacob Peterson Right Winger | 09/10 | Colorado Rapids Toronto FC | 92 | 11/12 | | 0 | 538 |
| Alan Gordon Centre-Forward | 10/11 | CD Chivas USA Toronto FC | 9 | 11/12 | | 62 | 122 |
| Dwayne de Rosario Attacking Midfield | 08/09 | Houston Dynamo FC Toronto FC | 78 | 10/11 | | 13 | 840 |
| Chris Konopka Goalkeeper | 07/08 | Sporting Kansas City Bohemian Football Club | 0 | 10/11 | | 0 | 1.155 |
| Nick LaBrocca Central Midfield | 09/10 | Colorado Rapids Toronto FC | 61 | 10/11 | | 63 | 351 |
| Carlos Ruiz Centre-Forward | 08/09 | Los Angeles Galaxy Toronto FC | 82 | 10/11 | | 14 | 914 |
| Carlos Ruiz Centre-Forward | 08/09 | Toronto FC Olimpia Asunción | 5 | 10/11 | | 14 | 761 |
| Jon Conway Goalkeeper | 09/10 | CD Chivas USA Toronto FC | 0 | 10/11 | | 6 | 296 |
| Chad Barrett Centre-Forward | 08/09 | Chicago Fire FC Toronto FC | 82 | 10/11 | | 45 | 914 |
| Kenny Cooper Jr. Centre-Forward | 09/10 | FC Dallas TSV 1860 Munich | 90 | 10/11 | | 34 | 518 |
| Tony Donatelli Central Midfield | 05/06 | Houston Dynamo FC Vancouver Whitecaps FC | 0 | 10/11 | | 0 | 1.767 |
| Hunter Freeman Right-Back | 08/09 | New York Red Bulls Toronto FC | 30 | 10/11 | | 23 | 810 |
| Hunter Freeman Right-Back | 08/09 | Toronto FC IK Start | 7 | 10/11 | | 23 | 699 |
| Khari Stephenson Attacking Midfield | 05/06 | Sporting Kansas City GAIS | 9 | 10/11 | | 81 | 1.650 |
| Gonzalo Segares Left-Back | 09/10 | Chicago Fire FC Apollon Limassol | 114 | 10/11 | | 117 | 217 |
| Scott Sealy Centre-Forward | 08/09 | San Jose Earthquakes Maccabi Tel Aviv | 14 | 09/10 | | 26 | 455 |
| Marvell Wynne Right-Back | 06/07 | New York Red Bulls Toronto FC | 29 | 09/10 | | 140 | 1.073 |
| Michael Umaña Centre-Back | 05/06 | Los Angeles Galaxy Brujas FC (- 2011) | 14 | 09/10 | | 50 | 1.520 |
| Adrian Serioux Defensive Midfield | 08/09 | FC Dallas Toronto FC | 34 | 09/10 | | 13 | 393 |
| Carlos Borja Left-Back | 07/08 | CD Chivas USA CD Tapatío | 0 | 09/10 | | 34 | 759 |
| Troy Perkins Goalkeeper | 07/08 | D.C. United Vålerenga Fotball Elite | 77 | 09/10 | | 22 | 731 |
| Daniel Hernández Defensive Midfield | 06/07 | New England Revolution Puebla FC | 42 | 09/10 | | 82 | 813 |
| Daniel Szetela Central Midfield | 07/08 | Columbus Crew Racing Santander | 34 | 09/10 | | 0 | 670 |
| Kevin Harmse Defensive Midfield | 07/08 | Los Angeles Galaxy Toronto FC | 17 | 08/09 | | 0 | 480 |
| Cornell Glen Centre-Forward | 06/07 | Los Angeles Galaxy San Juan Jabloteh | 4 | 08/09 | | 33 | 851 |