| Boy Deul Attacking Midfield | 16/17 | FC Emmen PFK Stal Kamyanske (-2018) | 56 | 18/19 | | 112 | 776 |
| Darren Maatsen Right Winger | 17/18 | Go Ahead Eagles Apollon Smyrnis | 17 | 18/19 | | 32 | 362 |
| Thomas Verheydt Centre-Forward | 17/18 | MVV Maastricht Crawley Town | 61 | 18/19 | | 30 | 375 |
| Randy Wolters Left Winger | 17/18 | Go Ahead Eagles Dundee FC | 29 | 18/19 | | 33 | 377 |
| Collin Seedorf Centre-Back | 17/18 | RKC Waalwijk Inverness Caledonian Thistle FC | 45 | 18/19 | | 149 | 367 |
| Jordie Briels Central Midfield | 17/18 | Fortuna Sittard Dundee United FC | 146 | 18/19 | | 1 | 354 |
| Tim Hölscher Defensive Midfield | 17/18 | Go Ahead Eagles Esbjerg fB | 12 | 18/19 | | 18 | 152 |
| Patrick N'Koyi Centre-Forward | 17/18 | MVV Maastricht Dundee United FC | 22 | 18/19 | | 6 | 365 |
| Ibrahim Maaroufi Defensive Midfield | 10/11 | MVV Maastricht Wydad Casablanca | 0 | 18/19 | | 0 | 2.922 |
| Koen van der Biezen Centre-Forward | 11/12 | Go Ahead Eagles Cracovia | 57 | 17/18 | | 29 | 2.396 |
| Soufyan Ahannach Left Winger | 17/18 | Almere City FC Brighton & Hove Albion | 85 | 17/18 | | 0 | 162 |
| Rodney Klooster Right-Back | 16/17 | FC Dordrecht AS Trencin | 4 | 17/18 | | 27 | 353 |
| Melvin Platje Centre-Forward | 15/16 | VVV-Venlo Stade Brestois 29 | 33 | 17/18 | | 35 | 750 |
| Sjoerd Overgoor Central Midfield | 16/17 | SC Cambuur Leeuwarden Szombathelyi Haladás | 0 | 17/18 | | 37 | 362 |
| Kai Heerings Centre-Back | 16/17 | SC Cambuur Leeuwarden SKN St. Pölten | 0 | 17/18 | | 11 | 370 |
| Agil Etemadi Goalkeeper | 16/17 | Almere City FC Sanat Naft FC | 60 | 17/18 | | 0 | 365 |
| Jesse Bertrams Goalkeeper | 16/17 | PSV Eindhoven U21 Lommel SK | 38 | 17/18 | | 9 | 349 |
| André Krul Goalkeeper | 16/17 | SC Cambuur Leeuwarden Iwaki FC | 0 | 16/17 | | 0 | 211 |
| Arsenio Valpoort Left Winger | 15/16 | RKC Waalwijk Beitar Jerusalem | 50 | 16/17 | | 40 | 357 |
| Barry Maguire Attacking Midfield | 15/16 | FC Den Bosch Sarpsborg 08 FF | 105 | 16/17 | | 0 | 496 |
| Ricardo Kip Attacking Midfield | 16/17 | Almere City FC Fleetwood Town | 118 | 16/17 | | 40 | 50 |
| Deniz Aslan Right-Back | 11/12 | Helmond Sport Bursaspor U21 | 9 | 16/17 | | 18 | 1.883 |
| Oguzhan Türk Attacking Midfield | 14/15 | VVV-Venlo Gaziantepspor (- 2020) | 34 | 16/17 | | 29 | 776 |
| Patrick N'Koyi Centre-Forward | 14/15 | Fortuna Sittard Petrolul Ploiesti | 59 | 16/17 | | 22 | 760 |
| Mawouna Amevor Centre-Back | 15/16 | Go Ahead Eagles Notts County | 0 | 16/17 | | 56 | 388 |